A Legal Slippery Slope

A conceptual slippery slope is an argument that suggests that while it is possible to switch between two things with a series of small, almost indistinguishable steps, there is no significant difference between these two things, and they should be treated in exactly the same way. For example, a conceptual slippery slope might include the argument that if we allow euthanasia for animals, there`s no reason why we shouldn`t allow it for humans as well. Volokh concludes by stating that the analysis of his article „implicitly refutes the argument that arguments with slippery slopes are inherently logically misleading: the claim that A`s will inevitably lead to B`s, by logical coercion, might be false, but the more modest claim that A`s could make B`s more likely seems plausible.” [24]: 1134 A similar conclusion was drawn by Corner et al., who, after examining the psychological mechanism of the slippery slope argument, say, „Despite their philosophical notoriety, SSAs are used (and appear to be accepted) in a variety of practical contexts. The experimental evidence reported in this article suggests that, in certain circumstances, their practical acceptance may be justified, not only because the theoretical framework of the decision makes them subjectively rational, but also because it shows how well the slippery slopes they claim to exist actually exist. [25]: 147 Walton, Douglas. 1992. Arguments on the Slippery Slope. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Therefore, the above slippery slopes are based on the need to deal with similar cases in a uniform manner. These inclinations often involve a positive feedback mechanism in which the first action in question triggers a chain reaction that amplifies itself. This potential feedback mechanism may be explicitly mentioned by the person proposing the slope, or it may be implicitly part of their reasoning. The prohibition of alcohol consumption, prostitution, gambling, etc.

does not lead to the elimination of these practices, either in an abusive or non-abusive form. Similarly, the choice is not between euthanasia and the absence of euthanasia, as abuse occurs only in the former. Instead, he chooses between euthanasia with or without regulation. Either way, there will be abuses, and assuming there is nothing wrong with euthanasia per se, we might as well legalize and regulate it. Therefore, the basic structure of a causal slippery slope is as follows: slippery slope arguments are widely used in many areas. For example, the following is an example of a slippery slope argument in the context of bioethics: Walton notes that these three characteristics will be common to all slippery slopes, but argues that there needs to be more clarity about the nature of the „mechanism” and a way to distinguish between slippery slope arguments and negative consequence arguments. [7]: 275 When a person is accused of using an argument with a slippery slope, it suggests that he is guilty of deceptive reasoning, and while asserting that p z implies, for some reason, this is not the case. In logic and critical thinking textbooks, arguments of slippery slopes and slippery slopes are usually discussed as a form of error, although there may be an acknowledgement that non-misleading forms of argumentation may also exist. [7]: 273–311 Van der Burg, Wibren. 1991. The Slippery Slope Argument.

Ethics 102(1): 42-65. Slippery slope arguments used in this way often involve extreme exaggerations that evoke strong emotions. As a result, slippery slopes are often combined with appeals to emotions, usually in order to process negative emotions such as fear or hatred, but sometimes in order to appeal to positive emotions such as hope or compassion. This article examines the Slippery Slope (SSA) argument in legal contexts from the perspective of pragma dialectics and explains the conditions under which an SSA schema instance is used reasonably (and not in a misleading manner). We look at SSA instances in previous legal decisions and analyze the basic SSA legal scheme. By illustrating the institutional premises that influence the reasoning with which an SSA advances, we identify three substems (causal SSA, analog SSA and Sorites SSA). For each sub-theme, we offer critical questions as well as four rules that clarify when the SSA scheme is used reasonably. Institutional preconditions make the SSA analogous expected in common law contexts; Sorites SSA is to be expected in civil law contexts; while causal SSA is common to both contexts. This result will be integrated into future work to identify typical argumentative models for SSA in legal contexts.

In this regard, slippery slopes on the previous plane usually involve a false dichotomy in which only two options are presented (either refuse to set a certain precedent, or create it and be forced to treat other cases in the same way in the future), while ignoring a third possibility, namely the fact that we can set a precedent now and that we will always be able to deal with other cases. differently. When it comes to conceptual slippery slopes, a proposed slope is usually misleading because it ignores the ability to distinguish two things, even though it is possible to move from one to the other with a series of small steps. Slippery slope arguments, regularly advanced in a variety of practical ethical contexts, assert that when a certain type of action (such as euthanasia) is allowed, society is inexorably led („on the slippery slope”) to allow other morally wrong actions. Schauer, Friedrich. 1985. Slippery Slopes. Harvard Law Review 99(2): 361-383. Various metaphors are often used to describe the concept of slippery slopes and in particular the concept of causal slippery slopes. The most commonly used metaphors for this purpose are: Note: Slippery slopes associated with a positive chain of events are sometimes called a representation of a positive cycle, while slippery slopes associated with a negative chain of events are sometimes called a vicious circle. Slippery slope arguments are not inherently misleading, and in some cases, a slippery slope argument may be a solid form of reasoning rather than a logical error.

For example, here is an example of a reasonable argument in favor of a slippery slope: In the context of euthanasia, the legal significance of the dispute over the slippery slope argument is enormous. The power of logical slippery slope arguments depends on the law-changing mechanism used and is weak unless the law-changing mechanism consists of rights or the defence of necessity. With regard to the empirical argument of the slippery slope, greater caution should be exercised before relying on the „Dutch experience” to discuss proposals to regulate euthanasia in other jurisdictions and the possible consequences of such regulation. In the Netherlands, there is no evidence that the legalisation of voluntary euthanasia has led to an increase in the rate of involuntary euthanasia.