Studies and surveys have shown that belief in astrology in Western countries is higher than one might otherwise expect. [13] In 2012, polls in polls indicated that 42% of Americans thought astrology was at least partially scientific. [55]: 7/25 This faith, which diminishes with education, is strongly correlated with the level of scientific knowledge. [13]: 345 Progress is defined here as the explanation of new phenomena and the solving of existing problems, but astrology has made no progress after having changed little in nearly 2000 years. [24]: 228 [25]: 549 For Thagard, astrologers act as if they were employed in normal science because they believe that the foundations of astrology are well established despite the „many unsolved problems” and in the face of better alternative theories (psychology). For these reasons, Thagard considered astrology to be a pseudoscience. [24]: 228 scientific disciplines based on hypotheses but without consistent supporting evidence are called pseudoscience. Astrology is one of them. The difference between science and pseudoscience is the difference between objective reality and subjective impressions. Pseudoscience distorts real scientific discoveries and contributes to anti-intellectual attitudes.
It replaces exploration and discovery with mysticism and magic. Astrologers vehemently deny this and firmly oppose any attempt to manipulate the veracity of astrology. For astrology to be economic, astrologers would have to produce results and data that cannot be easily explained by any means other than a new and undiscovered force capable of establishing a connection between an individual and bodies in space, influencing a person`s life, and based on the exact time of his birth. However, despite the millennia that astrologers had to work on this problem, nothing came. Testing the validity of astrology can be difficult because there is no consensus among astrologers on what astrology is or what it can predict. [3]: 83 Dean and Kelly documented 25 studies that found that the degree of agreement between astrologers` predictions was measured at a low 0.1. [d] [14]: 66 Most professional astrologers are paid to predict the future or describe a person`s personality and life, but most horoscopes only make vague and unverifiable statements that can apply to almost anyone. [3]: 83 Astrology has been criticized for not providing a physical mechanism that connects the movements of celestial bodies to their alleged effects on human behavior.
In a 2001 lecture, Stephen Hawking explained, „The reason most scientists don`t believe in astrology is because it doesn`t agree with our theories, which have been experimentally tested.” [39] In 1975, amid growing public interest in astrology, The Humanist magazine presented a refutation of astrology in a statement by Bart J. Bok, Lawrence E. Jerome, and Paul Kurtz. [11] The statement entitled „Objections to Astrology” was signed by 186 leading astronomers, physicists and scientists of the time. They said that there is no scientific basis for the principles of astrology and warned the public not to accept astrological advice without asking questions. Their criticism focused on the fact that there was no mechanism by which astrological effects could occur: through a process known as self-attribution, many studies have shown that individuals with knowledge of astrology tend to describe their personality in terms of traits compatible with their sun signs. The effect is amplified when individuals knew that the personality description was used to discuss astrology. People who were not familiar with astrology did not have such a tendency. [50] Even people who are skeptical of astrology can warm up to it if it evokes positive self-descriptions. This stimulus to pseudoscience is amplified by the deep wiring of our brain to see patterns and agents, even if there are none. In times of great stress, astrology predictions can give the illusion of control. Not knowing what the future holds may be untenable for some.