n. the power of a judge, public official or private party (under contractual, fiduciary or testamentary authority) to make decisions on various matters on the basis of his or her opinion within the framework of the general legal guidelines. Examples: (a) a judge may, at his or her discretion, decide on the amount of a fine or grant or whether to grant the continuation of the proceedings; (b) A trustee or executor of an estate may, at his or her discretion, allocate the assets among the beneficiaries provided that the value is approximately the same for each of them; (c) A district prosecutor may, at his discretion, charge a crime with misdemeanour (maximum penalty of one year) or a crime; (d) The Governor may, at his discretion, grant a pardon; or (e) a planning board may, in its sole discretion, grant or waive a waiver of a land use by-law. Not all discretionary uses by law enforcement are negative. They often use it to simplify and eliminate the real criminals of the average citizen. [9] DISCRETION, crim. Right. The ability to recognize and distinguish good from evil; between what is legal and what is illegal. 2. The age at which children are expected to have discretion is not determined very precisely.
Under seven years of age, it seems that no circumstance of malicious discretion can be admitted to overturn the strong presumption of innocence raised by such a tender age. 1 Hale, p. c. 27, 8; 4 Bl. Room. 13M Between the ages of seven and fourteen, the infant is prima facie deprived of his criminal intent, but this presumption diminishes with age and can be rebutted even during this break in adolescence by positive evidence of malicious intent; Because the tenderness of the years will not excuse a maturity in crime, which is the maxim in these cases, malitia supplet aetatem. At the age of fourteen, the children would have acquired legal discretion. 1 Hale, S.C. 25.
Discretion has the meaning of acting according to one`s own authority and judgment. Under the law, a judge may exercise discretion in court decisions, for example if evidence is excluded from a trial. Some see discretion negatively, while others see it positively. Discretion exists at all levels of law enforcement and among many types of front-line bureaucrats. Discretion was called „the art of adapting the plot to certain circumstances” (Lord Scarman). Those in positions of power are most often able to exercise discretion as to how they use or will exercise that power. The ability to make decisions that constitute responsible decisions and for which an understanding of what is legal, just or wise can be assumed. [1] Note: A public servant generally enjoys qualified immunity from actions arising from his or her discretionary actions. The term is often part of the warning „Viewer discretion is advised” in TV shows before the show begins. In this context, VDA implies that the content of the programme may not be suitable for young viewers; It`s too explicit in terms of nudity, violence, sexual content or language.
Excerpt from the book of sayings „Like a golden jewel in the muzzle of a pig, the same goes for a beautiful woman who is without discretion.” [14] „A misuse of authority is a failure to take into account the facts and law relating to a particular issue; an arbitrary or inappropriate deviation from precedents and regulated legal practices. [8] When appealing the exercise of judicial discretion, the term „abuse of power” is a standard of review that requires the Court of Appeal to conclude that the lower court`s decision „would shock the conscience of a reasonable person” in order to set aside the next decision. The term crime is defined as an act prohibited or restricted by law and enforced by punishment. [4] But where the law stops and the margin of appreciation begins is in the implementation of these laws. Law enforcement officers, the police, are responsible for enforcing these regulations, but they often have the discretion to lay charges and arrest them. For example, a traffic violation; The police officer can simply issue a warning. Indeed, discretion can be found at all stages of the criminal justice system. [5] The victim has the discretion to defend himself or herself and to report the crime from time to time. The chief of operations decides on the priority of the call, an officer who responds has the discretion to take testimony from witnesses and arrest potential suspects. The suspect/defendant has the discretion to hire a lawyer when pleading and accepting a plea.
The prosecutor has the choice (discretion of the prosecutor`s office) to pursue a case or drop the charges, as well as to propose plea negotiations. The judge has discretion whenever an objection is raised or evidence is presented. The jury has a margin of appreciation on the final verdict. These examples are only a small sample of the electoral chain that is criminal law. Thus, the official would then treat individuals differently. This can be an argument for or against the police, who show discretion. On the one hand, all people should be treated equally, regardless of race or economic status. On the other hand, the officer and public safety are the most important tasks for an officer. If a public servant can see that a particular area requires a different approach to ensuring that security, he or she should make appropriate use of that discretion. [6] The phrase can also be found in the fifth act, scene IV of Shakespeare`s play Henry IV, Part 1, which was pronounced by Falstaff to Prince Hal when he thought the former was dead. Falstaff, who had played the dead on the battlefield to avoid being killed,[12] told Hal: „The best part of bravery is discretion; how did I save my life. [13] The exercise of judicial discretion is an inherent aspect of judicial independence within the meaning of the doctrine of separation of powers.
The standard of review for appeals against decisions involving the exercise of discretion is „misuse of authority”. Prosecutors have an important discretionary role in the criminal justice process. You have the opportunity to initiate and terminate all lawsuits. They must exercise their discretion to assess the rights of the accused, the feelings of the victim and the ability of prisons to determine an appropriate sentence. Prosecutors control plea negotiations and therefore may have the most discretionary role in the criminal justice process. If they believe that a person deserves to be in prison, they will continue on this path, knowing that prisons are very full and would then lead to a person being released earlier without serving his full sentence. [7] DISCRETION, Practice. When it is said that something is left to the discretion of a judge, it means that he must decide according to the rules of justice and the nature of the circumstances. Louis. Code, art. 3522, No.
13; 2 Inst. 50, 298; 4 serg. & Rawle, 265; 3 ridges. 2539. 2. A judge`s discretion is called the law of tyrants; it is still unknown; it is different in men; It is casual and depends on constitution, temperament and passion.