Good Governance Rule of Law Transparency and Accountability

There is also disagreement about the extent to which the four principles actually form a unified program. Humanitarian organizations generally present them as such and summarize them in policy documents as a group that appears to be mutually reinforcing. And these principles have one thing in common – they all relate to the interaction of states and their peoples and indicate a greater role for citizens in the functioning of the state. In addition, in practice, there are natural links between them. Accountability programs, for example, often include transparency as a building block while relying on citizen participation, for example by supporting local groups that try to push a particular government institution to better respond to public concerns. Similarly, efforts to achieve greater inclusion naturally go hand in hand with greater public participation. But the links between the four principles are only partial. Part of accountability work involves working to improve the technical capacity of certain government agencies without attempting to improve participation or inclusion. Some transparency programs are narrowly designed to make government data more easily accessible to the private sector and other stakeholders, and do not consciously link these transparency mechanisms to accountability or participatory processes. Participatory development, on the other hand, often seeks to make participation itself the engine of change by helping citizens take responsibility for the development of their communities without fostering special links with formal accountability mechanisms.

And accountability programmes or participatory development efforts sometimes do not include marginalized groups and do not take into account their needs, even though efforts in this direction have gradually improved. In short, what is presented to the outside world as a unified agenda appears more within the development community as a set of goals competing with each other for attention and resources. Different organizations or support groups within them have very different relative emphases on the four principles. For example, enthusiastic advocates of the growing transnational movement for accountability and transparency see these issues as a potentially transformative step forward in the governance agenda and naturally accompanied by increasing efforts to harness new Internet and communication technologies for development. Other practitioners have long been committed to participatory development and/or socio-economic inclusion – two areas of support that emerged before the recent onslaught of attention for accountability and transparency and have undergone various permutations in recent decades. Not only are the four principles often pursued at least somewhat independently of each other, but they can also sometimes be in tension. For example, trying to hold a civil war government accountable for past rights violations may limit the inclusion of certain groups in the post-conflict political system. Accountability programs aimed at reducing government control may in fact seek to limit participation in the work of certain institutions, such as central banks, in order to insulate them from political pressures or improve their effectiveness. Some attempts to strengthen public sector accountability through increased competition in service provision can perpetuate patterns of marginalization, and poorly designed participatory projects can exacerbate rather than mitigate the exclusion of disadvantaged groups. These tensions are rarely acknowledged and remain buried under constant references to the four principles as a common agenda. In summary, the apparent consensus on transparency, accountability, participation and inclusion should be understood as an ongoing work, not as a transformation that has already been largely achieved.

Proponents of these principles should resist the temptation to pretend that the agreement around them is stronger than it really is – and they should be prepared to confront the many permanent fissures and look for ways to reduce them. Some, such as debates about the legitimacy of the intrinsic case, reflect differences in the basic idea of what development is and are therefore unlikely to be overcome anytime soon. But others, such as the persistent division between practitioners of governance, human rights and democracy, or the problem of superficial application of the four principles, are far more conducive to practical solutions. In other words, the actual solidification of the consensus will depend heavily on how effectively its proponents deepen their understanding of how the four approaches can be put into practice, clearly share this understanding among all parts of the aid community, and bridge the gap between donors and recipients on these issues. The degree of their success will be a critical factor in determining the direction of the next generation`s international development work. In short, good governance refers to the political and institutional processes and outcomes needed to achieve development goals. The real test of „good” governance is the extent to which it delivers on the promise of human rights: civil, cultural, economic, political and social. The key question is: Do government institutions effectively guarantee the right to health, adequate housing, adequate food, quality education, fair justice and personal security? The evidence-based debate for the four principles is rooted in the broader, often fierce, debate about the overall relationship between governance systems and economic development.