I have benefited from homeopathy for my long-standing throat problem. After an allopathic E&T specialist told me that allopathic treatment had ruined my throat by mistakenly removing my tonsils. He advised me to try a homeopathic treatment and it worked. No one denies that some people are genuinely convinced that they benefit from homeopathy. This is thanks to the placebo effect – the more you believe, the greater the effect. But no serious scientific study has ever shown anything beyond that. That is why a group of German professors and doctors, including Mr Schmacke, met in Freiburg earlier this year to make a statement. Homeopathy is „a belief system that stubbornly survives,” they argue, that „cannot be explained” and is based on the „self-deception” of patients and therapists. Mukerji says many people turn to homeopathy after hearing that it „works” for a friend or family member.
But, he says, it`s all too easy to assume that correlation means causation. „If you`ve seen a homeopath for severe headaches, chances are — no matter what that person does to you — that your headache won`t be as severe the next day,” he says. In such a situation, it is the passage of time that leads to physical improvement, not the sugar balls. In the United States, advocacy for homeopathy may be more subtle. When I consulted a specialist at the University of Maryland at Baltimore about peripheral neuropathy, I was told that she had no clues to its source, but some of her patients reported the benefits of an over-the-counter pill that turns out to be a homeopathic „remedy”: Box instructions: Place a few pills (dextrosis) under your tongue when you go to bed. Cavities, anyone? Where is „First, do no harm”? And yet, trust in homeopathy is widespread, especially in Europe. In Hahnemann`s home country of Germany, homeopathic treatments are prescribed by doctors, covered by 70% of government medical plans, and offered in almost all pharmacies. In a 2014 survey, 60% of Germans said they had tried homeopathy. The country`s homeopathic pharmaceutical market is worth around $750 million (€670 million), with consumers paying largely out of pocket. Consulting fees amount to hundreds of millions more.
In 1978, homeopathy was legally recognized in § 25 (2) no. 2 of the Medicines Act. and § 105 Abs. 4F as a special therapeutic approach – „Special therapeutic direction”. In recent years, several people in Germany have looked at the evidence on homeopathy from very different angles and found that it is hopelessly flawed. Independently, they published articles and books about their research and discoveries. Here are 5 examples: I just received the news that the Board of Directors of the Bavarian Medical Association unanimously decided at the meeting of 5.12. Remove complementary training in homeopathy from the Regulation respecting medical education. UNANIMOUSLY!!! 11 out of 17 medical societies have kicked homeopathy. That leaves 6. The next decision will take place in Berlin. But lobbyists pushed to exempt homeopathy.
Currently, manufacturers of homeopathic medicines only have to prove that the ingredients in their products do not cause direct harm. And if a company wants to market a homeopathic remedy to treat certain diseases, it is enough for a group of homeopathic practitioners to confirm the effectiveness of the products with a handful of case studies. The process is known as „internal consensus” and is one of the most debated aspects of homeopathy. In Germany, there is no legal monopoly on the practice of medicine. Doctors and alternative practitioners are allowed to practice. However, there are some restrictions on performing certain medical actions. Only doctors are authorized to treat sexually transmitted diseases, treat communicable and epidemic diseases, dispense certain medicines, administer or provide anesthetics and narcotics, perform obstetrics and gynaecology, take X-rays, perform autopsies and issue death certificates. Violations may be prosecuted. Medical sham has a long tradition in Germany, where alternative practitioners or „alternative practitioners” are allowed to offer medical services despite a lack of medical training. The law dates back to 1939, which is no coincidence: the main Nazis pushed for homeopathy as an alternative to „Jewish” [i.e. scientific] medicine. As one researcher described it, alternative medicine is a „relic of the Nazis that endangers public health.” By the way, some members of the right still call vaccination campaigns „fascist.” But the real Nazis were anti-vaxxers.
There is more recent support for homeopathy and I applaud the unexplained concept of the placebo effect. This would require special studies. Near Toulouse in France, there is a laboratory with a group of electronics engineers working on something inexplicable but really effective: „bio-photonic bridges” applied to different schemes.