Whether you use Smart Projex, which has a system that reminds you that a quality objective needs to be tested or that a test has failed, you need to have a system in place to ensure that your quality tests are actually performed and that the test results have been verified. At the 2015 LegalTech conference in Atlanta, I listened to several speakers talk about whether hiring high-quality lawyers can save money. But if the company doesn`t have a quality management process, are you really saving money? Given the fierce competition for clients and the desire expressed by many corporate clients to keep as much work in-house as possible, it is indispensable for businesses at all levels of the legal profession. Large companies must prove that their premium prices are justified, while small companies must be challenged to prove that their work is at the same level as large law firms that are „less risky to hire.” Older lawyers need to show that their skills have not diminished and that they are capable of thriving in a technology-driven legal world. Young lawyers, on the other hand, must eliminate the perception that they lack the attention to detail and work ethic that were hallmarks of earlier eras of legal practice. Everyone has something to prove – all the time. Sure. A small law firm had a wealthy client with a range of business interests. One day, this client passed by unexpectedly. He simply wanted to give a small file to his lawyer, the founder of this company. The reason given was that he was cleaning his office and wanted to keep all his legal acts in one place.
He said the case was about a debt owed to him, but added that he did not believe he would ever do anything about it. The lawyer accepted the file, which was filed shortly thereafter along with all of this client`s other files. Counsel had intended to review the file in advance, but due to other priorities and given the client`s testimony, this review never took place. After more than a year, this lawyer finally learned two things. First, his client had recently died; Second, although the now deceased client never expressed a desire to continue collecting this outstanding debt, his executor wanted to do so. The lawyer was ordered to withdraw the file and take all necessary legal measures. Unfortunately, after the file was withdrawn and reviewed, this lawyer suddenly realized that a critical deadline for her supervision had passed. Debts were no longer recoverable. One thing is clear: law firms need to create a legal quality management process in their law firms. Whether your job involves reviewing documents as part of an eDiscovery effort, testifying with key witnesses, preparing preliminary surety documents, or coding software for an extension of your company`s new time management and accounting software, the challenge is the same. What are the quality objectives required to ensure that the outcome of this activity meets the client`s needs and leads to the success of the project? Write down the answer.
Major errors in quality control are obviously not limited to the legal world. Mistakes in other industries can be much more serious, even fatal. One of the most notorious „product defects” was, for example, the Ford Pinto, a small car with the unfortunate tendency to ignite in the rear – with tragic consequences. There is no doubt that Ford`s engineers were all competent people and could have designed the car`s faulty fuel tank better. At the same time, executives placed unreasonable expectations on the engineering team to develop a cheap vehicle because they had made unachievable promises to investors. To make matters worse, Ford`s culture at the time suffered from a tendency to ignore junior staff. It wasn`t until a senior engineer literally saw the charred shell of a Pinto and reported that Ford had corrected the quality control failure. Law firms` mistakes may not be as deadly as Ford`s, but the consequences for firms that ignore their quality control responsibilities could be extremely serious for the firm and its clients.
It is best to drive carefully. Abundance. It`s about building and maintaining a reputation. Quality control processes will help you achieve this. For Wendy`s, they wanted to be known for consistently delivering a big, tasty burger. They made a promise and consistently applied it because they developed very effective quality control processes at each of their sites. For a law firm, when a new case is taken on, a lawyer makes a similar promise: to deliver the promised product or service on time and thoroughly. However, the interesting question for you is this. Does every lawyer in your firm consistently keep their promise with every client? Remember that everyone`s reputation is at stake with every promise. This includes tightening processes to improve efficiency, avoid waste, and reduce the number of times we have to touch the same sheet of paper. I know that the legal community is making ongoing efforts to use Six Sigma principles and improve processes to streamline work. It doesn`t matter if your tests involve a fairly simple verification of the result or a complicated error measurement log.
Someone must be responsible for approving or disapproving the results of quality tests. Who will he be? You guessed it…, write it down. In the absence of a quality control process, how would you know if a file is currently in someone`s drawer, or a reminder note to look at a file that happens to be buried under a mountain of paper? In either case, it`s all too easy to forget completely, and that`s exactly what happened here. If one of this company`s quality controls were a formal file review process, the file in question would have been reviewed well before the critical deadline had expired. The lawyer would have had the opportunity not only to discuss the legal consequences of the expiry of this time limit, but also to document the client`s decision either to protect his rights or to do nothing about it. While there are other quality control procedures you can implement in your business, a customer business review process is at the heart of quality control because it is designed to prevent a case from falling through the cracks and customers from being forgotten. Admittedly, aside from a long-term customer spike, you`re unlikely to hear a customer utter the words „Where`s the beef?” With such a process, I hope you never hear anything like it, something like, „How the hell did this happen?” Every lawyer, and therefore every law firm, strives to provide quality work. Clients demand it, the legal system demands it, and most of us have egos that demand it. At the same time, lawyers are fallible and companies still struggle to maintain quality standards – especially when businesses grow or decline, which seems to be the norm in this more fluid era of legal practice. Add to that the challenging atmosphere of recruiting and training new lawyers, and it`s no surprise that quality control is an important issue for law firms.
I take issue with their premise that a lawyer can get a 99% success rate on a document with only one pass, unless we are talking about the most basic documents. But I totally agree that most law firms, in fact most companies, could use substantial improvements in their quality management programs. I am a big believer in integrating quality into all your project plans, rather than trying to improve quality at the end. There are four steps to quality management that would benefit law firms and other businesses. By defining, reviewing, and establishing quality early and frequently, your law firm will save money, improve client relationships, and achieve better legal outcomes. And then you can incorporate the lessons you`ve learned into your next project. To learn more, click here. Many case management systems are designed to do this automatically, and these programs allow you to set how often you want to perform file analysis. The key to how this process works is that every question (regardless of time or type of material) must be entered into the system.