The Canadian, New Zealand and Australian laws have all followed the CDU`s pragmatic approach of adopting much of the terminology and framework of Article 9. However, New Zealand, as a unitary State, needed to enact only one law for the whole country and could create a single national „registry” of security interests. While the United States adopts Article 9 at the state level and Canada adopts its PPSA at the provincial level, Australia, another common law association, has deliberately implemented its new security law at the federal level to replace more than 70 state laws and create a national registry similar to New Zealand`s. A legally binding assignment can only assign existing debts. Only an equitable assignment can transfer rights under future contracts. This chapter describes how to use property concepts to perform a security function. The security function is to reinforce the fulfillment of a personal obligation, usually the payment of a sum of money. In the case of movable property, the security right may take one of four forms. He can take possession of a lien or pledge (or pledge). In addition to liens and privileges, there are non-possessory security rights in mortgages and charges, the latter of which may be fixed or floating.
Mortgages can be legal or cheap, but the fees are fair because they don`t involve a transfer of ownership, legal or cheap. Liens are always legal and privileges can be legal Some economists question the usefulness of collateral and secured loans in general. Proponents argue that secured interest reduces risk for the lender and, in turn, allows it to charge lower interest rates, thereby reducing the cost of capital for the borrower. Critics argue that secured creditors can destroy businesses that are in financial difficulty, but could still recover and be profitable. Secured lenders could get nervous and enforce collateral sooner, repossess important assets, and force the company into bankruptcy. In addition, the general principle in most insolvency regimes that creditors should be treated equally (or pari passu) and that secured creditors should receive preferential treatment for certain assets disrupts the conceptual basis for insolvency. [b] Some obligations are covered only by a security right in certain nominated assets and the liability for repayment of the debt is limited to the property itself, with no further claims being made against the debtor. These are called „non-recourse obligations.” In many common law systems, a legal lien includes the right to retain physical possession of tangible assets as security for the underlying obligations. In some countries, this is a form of possession security right, and title to the assets must be transferred to (and retained by) the secured party. In the case of a lien of possession, the right is purely passive. In the case of a lien of possession, the secured party (the lie)[27] does not have the right to sell the property, but only the right to refuse restitution until payment.
In the United States, a lien can be a non-proprietary security right. Many jurisdictions allow the mortgage of certain assets without transferring ownership of the assets to the mortgagee. Essentially, legal hypothecs relate to land, registered aircraft and registered vessels. In general, the mortgagee has the same rights as with a traditional authentic legal hypothec, but the method of enforcement is usually regulated by law. The different types of security rights that may arise and the rights they confer vary from country to country. [6] A tax does not include the transfer of ownership or possession of property. For practical reasons, most lenders will not want to take possession of the borrower`s assets, nor will the borrower want to lose control of them, especially if these assets are used in day-to-day business operations. As a result, a lender (secured creditor) will instead want to provide security by obtaining rights to certain assets of the borrower (chargor) as collateral for the loan. The debtor then has the right to use this asset to repay the debt. In the late 1940s, the U.S. legal community reached a consensus that traditional common law distinctions were outdated and useless. They tended to create too many unnecessary disputes as to whether the creditor had chosen the right type of security.
It was increasingly recognized that the various types of security had developed only because, on the one hand, many judges felt that there was something fundamentally wrong with allowing a person, out of desperation or folly, to unceremoniously encumber all his personal property as security for a loan, but on the other hand, Debtors and creditors would try to: achieve the desired result by all necessary means, even if it means having to create several security rights to cover different types of personal property. [40] There was also the problem of the early English cases mentioned above, which regarded these security interests as fraudulent transports and did not recognize that they had legitimate uses in a modern industrial economy. Given that the history of security rights has shown that judicial resistance to enforcement of general security rights would not deter debtors from giving them as an incentive for creditors to increase their financing, and that they were socially useful in the right circumstances, the best choice was to make security rights law as clear and simple as possible. When a borrower gets a loan from a bank, the bank will often want collateral for the loan it provides. Effective collateral for an asset means that if the borrower goes bankrupt, the bank can take possession of that asset, sell it, and use the proceeds to repay the loan. This puts the bank in a stronger position than creditors who do not have collateral. Without perfection, it may be difficult for the holder of the security right to enforce its rights in the security right against third parties, including a trustee and other creditors asserting a security right in the same security right. Lenders often take collateral as support for a borrower`s obligations under a loan. Security means that they have certain rights to the secured assets in case the borrower does not repay the loan. An equitable lien essentially takes effect as an equitable charge and arises only in certain situations (for example, an unpaid seller`s lien on property is an equitable lien; a maritime lien is sometimes considered an equitable lien). It is sometimes argued that if a corporation`s governing documents provide that the corporation has a lien on its own shares, that provision becomes effective as an equitable lien,[29] and if this analysis is correct, then it is probably the only exception to the rule that equitable liens arise by operation of law and not by agreement. In 2002, the Organization of American States promulgated the Inter-American Model Law on Secured Transactions in response to a growing body of empirical evidence that the chronic inability of Latin American legal systems to support modern asset-based financing is a major cause of economic instability in the region.
The OAS Model Law aimed to import many of the best parts of Article 9 of the CDU into the area of Latin American civil law, but with extensive revisions for the region`s unique problems. The OAS Model Law has been promulgated to some extent in several countries, including Mexico (2000, 2003 and 2010), Peru (2006), Guatemala (2007) and Honduras (2009). A secured creditor assumes a security interest to enforce its rights in a pledged asset if the debtor defaults on its obligation. If the debtor goes bankrupt, a secured creditor has priority over unsecured creditors in the distribution. Pledges or „trust receipts” are relatively rare forms of security in which the underlying assets are pledged not by handing them over as in a traditional pledge, but by handing over a document or other proof of ownership. The pledge is generally considered in relation to the merits (cf. bills of lading), the bill of lading being confirmed by the secured party who, if the guarantee is not honoured, can claim ownership by handing over the invoice. The security right assigned to the secured party is legal or equitable. Some security interests may be legal or cheap, some are always legal and some fair.
This depends on the type of security taken out and, in the case of mortgages, whether the criteria of a legal hypothec are met. For more information, see Mortgages. A mortgage can be legal or cheap. Under a legal hypothec, legal ownership of the property is transferred to the lender. An adequate mortgage is usually established when a transaction does not meet the formal requirements of a legal hypothec but is registered in equity (for example, a mortgage on real estate that the mortgage debtor does not yet own – a legal mortgage can only be created on real estate existing at that time); or if the mortgage concerns real estate that is only included in equity (for example, an equity interest – a legal mortgage cannot be assumed on real estate that is registered only in equity).