In summary, one could therefore be faced with a scenario in which the allegations are that the ship is unfit for navigation due to deficiencies in the transit plan itself and/or because the officers in charge have one or more of the above characteristics, as highlighted in the „EURASIAN DREAM”. At this point, the master of the vessel discusses with the Chief of Navigation (usually the second officer) how he intends to get to the port of destination. (In some cases, it may be necessary for the captain to plan the passage.) This is the process of collecting all information relevant to the proposed passage, including the identification of risks and the assessment of their critical areas. This includes information extracted from publications and from the diagram. The assessment will include details on: Based on the results of the condition assessment program and internal investigations of relevant claims, the club has identified the following aspects that are often missing from proper passage planning: When working in a team environment, the passage plan should be communicated to the navigation team at a pre-trip conference to ensure that all team members have the same pattern. mental of the whole journey. divide. [5] Travel planning begins with evaluation. Before each trip begins, the navigator must develop a detailed mental model of how the entire trip will unfold.
[5] The assessment phase involves collecting and reviewing all information relevant to the trip. Much of this assessment is done by consulting nautical charts, nautical publications, and performing a range of technical tasks such as weather forecasting, forecasting tides and currents, and reviewing local regulations and warnings. [6] The guidelines indicate that the passage plan should always be made available to the OOW on deck. The guidelines also specify that deviations from the plan must be clearly documented and consistent with the other provisions of the guidelines. [12] The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, in its judgment of 10. November 2021 upheld the judgments of the lower courts in this case, in which it was confirmed that a faulty passage plan can render a ship unfit for navigation Each step of the planning of the passage has its own meaning and it is extremely important to carry out each of them with the utmost care and up-to-date seamanship to ensure safe navigation. Passage planning consists of four phases: assessment, planning, execution and monitoring. [2] These steps are defined in International Maritime Organization Resolution A.893(21), Guidelines for Voyage Planning[3], which are in turn reflected in the local laws of IMO signatory States. [4] The guidelines set out fifty elements of crossing planning, some of which are applicable only in certain situations. [5] This is an important decision that underscores the utmost importance of careful and accurate planning of passages by navigation officers on board and does not significantly alter it. It should be recalled that it is stated in the „CMA CGM LIBRA” that a ship may be considered unfit for navigation if the passage plan is so defective that it does not meet the long-established criterion (McFadden -v- Blue Star Line [1905] 1 KB 697), that a prudent owner, if he had known of the defect in advance, would have made it necessary to repair it before the ship`s departure.
It is equally well known that a ship can be as unfit for navigation because of the skill or efficiency of its master and/or crew as it is because of the condition of the hull and equipment (The Eurasian Dream [2002] 1 Lloyds Rep 719). Similarly, the authorities are aware that an error does not necessarily mean that a particular crew member is not competent, nor is there any authority to suggest that the officer in question must have committed a number of similar acts before his or her abilities are deemed to have fallen to a level warranting a determination of unseaworthiness. In each individual case, it will be necessary to determine whether the facts of the case support the conclusion that the person concerned suffered from either a `disabling lack of skills` or a `disabling lack of knowledge`.