Legal Challenges of Metaverse

Imagine that one avatar attacks another. Could we apply the criminal assault and assault laws to this situation? How can we hold an avatar accountable for their actions in the metaverse? This would be complicated because it would mean that we would have to give the avatar a legal entity that gives him rights and obligations within a jurisdiction; Allow you to sue or be sued. However, like any new fundamental technology, the Metaverse remains confusing and unknown to many. So what exactly is the metaverse? What use cases for Metaverse currently exist and which ones are we waiting for? What laws apply to the Metaverse? We explore these and other questions in more detail in this article. If the rights to the content belong to third parties, a company creating a virtual experience on a Metaverse platform must ensure that its license from the intellectual property owner or licensor is broad enough to cover the development and licensing of content for virtual experiences on the Metaverse platforms. Even if the Company owns the intellectual property rights in the Content, it may already have licensed the intellectual property rights relevant to the use of Metaverse to third parties. Content owners need to understand their license limits and usage rights. There have already been lawsuits over the use of celebrity lookalikes used in video games, and these types of litigation could grow exponentially in the metaverse, as some avatars will also create commercial value. The possibilities of the metaverse are new and are likely to evolve over time as technology evolves.

Creators who create Metaverse projects should consider at least the following. Over the past decade, virtual interactions have become an increasingly important part of consumer and business lives. This trend has accelerated during the COVID-19 pandemic, as consumers and businesses turn to video conferencing and other forms of virtual interaction. Recently, interest in virtual interactions has focused on the „Metaverse,” with major companies, including Facebook, announcing Metaverse initiatives. In fact, Facebook, which predicts the Metaverse as the next wave of technology, has gone so far as to include the term in its new name, Meta. Governments around the world and the tech industry itself need to assess the validity of regulations like GDPR as international borders collapse into the metaverse. Developers need immediate guidance to create privacy-focused Metaverse experiences and age-centric experiences. Although everything sounds very exciting, a curious lawyer like me is inclined to ask: Who or what governs the metaverse? In my view, there are three key areas that are not legally clear at this stage. Although the scope of IP protection in the Metaverse is unclear, the new NFT marketplace has already seen a number of IP disputes. The possibility of disputes in the metaverse is even greater.

Companies and developers need to carefully consider whether they have the necessary intellectual property rights for the proposed use in a metaverse, and traditional approaches to enforcing intellectual property rights can be revised or significantly challenged, as we have seen in recent years with intellectual property embedded in user-generated content. The trademarks have filed lawsuits for dilution and infringement of marks related to Metaverse`s products and services. For example, Hermès sued Mason Rothschild for trademark infringement for his creation and sale of „Metabirkins,” NFTs attached to digital images showing bags similar to Hermès` Birkin bags. The case is still pending in the Southern District of New York. In dismissing Rothschild`s motion to dismiss, Judge Rakoff considered Rothschild`s argument that the Metabirkins NFTs were First Amendment protected artistic creations. Judge Rakoff held that these NFTs were likely protected artistic productions under the higher standards set by the Second Circuit precedent in Rogers v. Grimaldi, 875 F.2d 994 (2d cir. 1989). However, Judge Rakoff dismissed the motion to dismiss a plausible misleading mark charge.

The court also noted that the outcome might have been different if Rothschild had practically sold portable bags. The fully immersive metaverse is based on Web 3.0 technologies, including blockchain, cryptocurrencies, and non-fungible tokens (NFTs). We`ve already seen large companies accept cryptocurrencies as payment for goods and services, and El Salvador was recently the first country to adopt Bitcoin cryptocurrency as a second legal tender. In a fully immersive metaverse, trading can use cryptocurrencies in return. Digital products, whose ownership is often tracked with NFTs, have had great success recently, further demonstrating business opportunities in the Metaverse. The idea is to create real environments in the Metaverse. In this world, brands and tech companies can reach consumers in the same way they do in real life. Companies that have already entered this space or plan to include Samsung, Walmart, McDonald`s, fashion brands in Decentraland Fashion Week, Meta (Facebook), Sotheby`s and JP Morgan. Other companies buy virtual properties on Decentraland and Sandbox to promote and sell products and services. As mentioned above, several aspects of the current versions of the Metaverse are already in use and/or in the late stages of development. The need for humanity to advance its experiences in commerce, entertainment, and education, especially in a world where face-to-face interaction is prohibited or discouraged due to health risks, has led to rapid progress in the development of the Metaverse in a number of key areas, which will be discussed in more detail below.

Despite the widespread discussion about the metaverse as if it were already an existing, ready-made construct, the metaverse is currently little more than a rapidly evolving idea. The discussion about the Metaverse in 2022 could be a bit like the discussion on the internet in the 1960s. In both cases, even computer scientists can only imagine what the future might bring. Modern writers and filmmakers like Ernest Cline and Steven Spielberg – who worked on Ready Player One – have only given us a glimpse of how they envision an aspect of the Metaverse. Sports and entertainment memorabilia and collectibles in traditional and virtual form will also find increasing acceptance in the Metaverse in the form of traditional NFTs or NFTs with real-world components. For example, the NFL has created NFT virtual commemorative tickets for its games. Other leagues and events have sold NFTs that provide access to real experiences and benefits. The Metaverse has also sparked interest in sports memorabilia and collectibles that exist exclusively in the virtual world. ZED RUN, for example, combines NFT, cryptocurrency, and blockchain technology to create digital horse racing that allows its users to buy, trade, breed, and race their digital horses. The „metaverse” seems to be the latest buzzword when it comes to technology.