Legal Fees in Consolidation

See id., pp. 7-16 (distribution of lawyers` fees with the support of a special master). For examples where the court awarded funds following objections from some lawyers, see Victor, 623 F.3d at 84, In re Vitamins Antitrust Litig., 2011 WL 2732563 at *214, and Order and Reasons, op. cit. cit., note 14, pp. 8-9. The issue of the distribution of fees among MDL lawyers is an important but neglected issue in the legal literature. The existing literature on the principle of sole principal and single agent offers a partial solution, but it only tells the courts how to determine the total amount of fees owed to lawyers, not how to allocate them. At the same time, the current court practice of relying on a modified method of lodestar to support cost-sharing is reviving old complaints about lodestar and its inefficiencies. SimpleLegal`s expense management solution gives you complete visibility into your legal spend. Sign up for a demo to learn how a platform like SimpleLegal can be used to monitor external attorney billing to detect inaccuracies and apply AFAs and discounts to reduce M&A legal fees without sacrificing the quality of legal services.

The Silver Miller solution is innovative, but has several drawbacks. First, for the strategy to work, the designated monitor cannot entrust himself with pre-trial work. This means that the contracted business necessarily loses a significant stream of work and potential revenue. There is no guarantee that the rest will be as lucrative as the legal work itself. Second, in many consolidated MDLs, no single law firm has an overwhelming share of clients, so these strong incentives for surveillance can be hard to find. Thirdly, the proposal is an ex ante system. A court must have the foresight to order the controller in advance. Silver-Miller can only prevent attorneys` fee disputes in the future, it does not help resolve attorneys` fee disputes after they arise.

Often, it can be difficult to identify the nature or purpose of certain fees. For example, fees paid to an investment banker for debt financing and advisory fees related to an acquisition. In these cases, it may be useful to determine an appropriate allocation basis or to hire a professional to conduct a transaction cost analysis. Legal fees for mergers and acquisitions are usually high, and sometimes the numbers on the final bill are a surprise. You can reduce the likelihood of surprises if you proactively manage the M&A process and associated expenses. Not surprisingly, almost half of the remaining companies filed formal objections to the proposed split. Some suggested using a neutral third party such as a special master. Instead, the judge made some minor changes and awarded the fees as proposed. The dissatisfied lawyers then appealed the award to the Third Circuit, which eventually upheld the award after another two years of litigation. All told, the legal fee dispute lasted almost as long as it took lawyers to get the NFL`s initial $1 billion settlement. As the reader will recall, the fundamental problem with legal fees in the context of mass litigation is the absence of an involved and demanding client. So one solution is simply to make one, and that`s exactly what Charlie Silver and Geoff Miller propose.

They propose that the court designate the lawyer with the most clients in the MDL as lead counsel. This lawyer cannot work for the common benefit of the MDL (to prevent related party transactions), but this lawyer decides who performs community service and how much these lawyers will eventually be paid for community service. Senior counsel then taxes all cases, including his own, at the same rate to pay for the community service thus maintained (Silver & Miller 2010). As a result, the MDL context does not have the usual mechanisms that incentivize lawyers` behaviour and determine their fees. The conventional structure in which clients hire, pay and supervise lawyers collapses because clients are effectively absent.8 Courts choose lawyers, and courts are ill-placed to negotiate terms or oversee lawyers` performance. The courts have neither the time nor the interest and are traditionally passive institutions (Fitzpatrick, 2009). In addition to the price paid for the asset itself, additional costs may also be considered part of the acquisition if these costs are directly related to the acquisition process. For example, if the asset in question requires legal assistance to complete the transaction, legal and regulatory fees are also taken into account. Commissions related to the purchase can also be included, such as: to a real estate agent in the execution of a real estate transaction, to a recruitment company for the placement of an employee, to a marketing company for customer acquisition or to an investment bank for the mediation of a merger. The best way to reduce costs at this stage is to negotiate discounts and alternative fee agreements (AFAs) such as fixed or fixed fees, task-based fees, and more predictable blended rates. When negotiating, focus on the value of lawyers` work to your business, rather than the time it takes them to complete it.