License Vs Legalism

Even though I write and teach about it, I know my own heart. I am just as prone as anyone else to be wrong in both legalism and licensing. I have found that I do both. I don`t claim to be the biblical expert on how God thinks about your sexuality. But I love God and cling to His Word, believing that He proclaims truths that can set us free. Most people who practice licensing have never really seen that they are sinners. They think Christianity is a religion or a list of teachings to follow. They know little about true repentance and conversion. So they say they believe, but a new birth never took place (John 3:3). But while we may agree and maybe even buy a cup of coffee with it, far too few actually live this way. We don`t believe that „there is nothing we can do to make God love us less,” so we live in condemnation of all that we do wrong. Then we began to be as religiously and morally pure as possible to satisfy that insatiable voice.

This is a version of legalism. Just try not to do it wrong so you don`t lose God`s love and approval. It is unfortunate for a legalist to believe that he must meet certain conditions to be justified. It is also unfortunate that he learns that he is a legalist and throws the law completely overboard out of conviction. The solution to legalism is not antinomianism. Similarly, it is unfortunate that an antinomian realizes that he lives a lawless life. And thus introduces the law into his life until it spills over into his understanding of justification. The solution to antinomianism is not legalism. Legalism and antinomianism are two sides of the same coin because they are both „carnal” ways of life.

Christians should not try to find some mysterious middle ground between legality and license. The solution to both errors is gospel clarity, and the gospel teaches that there is a clear difference between justification and sanctification. If you claim to be a follower of Christ, God`s Word has pretty clear teachings about many sexual issues we face. We may not like this, but we know from Scripture what God says about adultery, pornography, homosexuality, and sleeping together outside of marriage. We can also see that God celebrates the beautiful expression of sexual passion in marriage. On many topics that are not so clear, the Bible gives principles to help us make wise and God-honoring choices. Accepting what the Bible teaches about sex is another matter. Each of us will tend to fall into one of two traps: legalism and licensing. Note that legalism is the opposite of the moral spectrum of licensing.

Legalism seeks to be just through works, and license claims justice without works. Globally, licensing is more common than legalism. I say this because we are programmed to sin by doing what we want to do. The only time we become legalistic is when this inveterate, self-centered desire meets rules and religion. Then we say, „Well, to save my skin, I`d better start doing this, this or that.” Then license takes the form of legalism, because now we are making our own, self-designed salvation. There is an astonishing self-deception about legalism. Most legalists usually say, „Everything is by God`s grace, but God requires obedience for His grace.” Incredibly, this statement shows exactly what legalism is! God cannot „demand” anything for His grace. That is why it is grace! It`s free. There are no conditions or requirements.

Obedience is not a prerequisite for grace, it is the result of grace. Until we see this and understand why, we will never see the truth. Is God`s law binding on Christians saved by grace? If this question is answered incorrectly, Christians can develop an attitude of legalism or freedom. However, the gospel teaches us to avoid both. Just to be clear, when I refer to God`s law, I am referring specifically to His moral commandments (the most well-known being the Ten Commandments). To help us reflect and live the role of God`s law for believers today, here are some principles we should keep in mind. Which mistake is more prevalent in the world – legalism or licensing? The word antinomy (as I use it) means „against the law.” This view holds that since God justifies the wicked by grace alone, then once a person is converted, he has no real benefit to the law – Christians have a „license to sin” because grace forgives completely. Some versions of antinomianism would even say that the law is dangerous to the healthy Christian life because it engenders complacency. Another gospel will not work. Adding to the gospel, as we try to do when we become legalistic, will not work. To allow the gospel is to follow „another gospel” and not the gospel that leads to freedom.

Perhaps the best-known example of legalism in the New Testament comes from the Epistle to the Galatians. The apostle Paul attacked false teachers in Galatia who were preaching „another gospel.” The practice of legalism that leads to frustration It is not that the Christian life is without norms. God`s righteous standard is eternal (Isaiah 51:6, 8). Rather, we now have a new desire and strength (through God`s Spirit) to live a life that pleases Him. But this brings us to the question of legalism. Charles Ryrie says in his beautiful book Balancing the Christian Life: „Legalism is not the presence of laws. Legalism can be defined as a carnal attitude that conforms to a code in order to elevate itself” (p. 159).

In other words, it is not „legalistic” to have moral standards. Legalism is the belief that God`s acceptance must be won through our good works. It involves a failure to understand and appreciate God`s grace and love. The only way to find a balance between legalism and freedom is to remember the correct relationship between the biblical gospel and ethics. „We must protect grace from the falsification of legalism, and we must protect the law from corruption from antinomianism” (John Murray). It can be tempting for someone who realizes they have legalistic tendencies to try to solve the problem from an antinomian perspective (or vice versa). This unfortunate shift often occurs when a Christian`s theology develops. But there is no point in leaving one mistake to another. The Christian life is also afflicted by two mortal enemies that are by no means mythological: legalism on the one hand and antinomianism (or license) on the other.

And both are deadly. I don`t mean that license is the worst sin. In fact, Jesus seems to have the harshest words for the Pharisees, not for the harsh. This is because the Pharisees knew so much, pretended, and were so corrupt inside. Their legalism and aspirations, both religious and moral, did not make the Pharisees any less wicked to Jesus. It made them even worse. Others may hear: „. nothing.

may God love you more,” but neither do we believe it, and we try to add something to the simple gospel that says, „All we have to do to receive God`s love and approval is to trust in Christ`s finished work on the cross.” So we add lists and rules and regulations. A list of rules, do`s and don`ts that we try to keep. as if they had been transmitted by God. (The Jewish Torah added 613 rules to God`s law.) We are not very different.