EMTALA`s protection cannot adequately guarantee to uninsured elderly patients seeking hospital treatment that they are protected from patient dumping. While older adults who are not Medicare or privately insured may have an increased risk of discharge, these individuals may also be denied appropriate emergency medical treatment for other reasons.28 For example, some unethical physicians discriminate against people with illnesses such as AIDS. 29 and other physicians prefer to treat patients with simple diseases rather than patients with complex illnesses, to reduce their risk of malpractice.30 Although patients „have the right to refuse” „Medical treatment” cases have difficulty discontinuing their medical care, many people have difficulty receiving medical care because they are denied admission to hospital. This problem is called „patient dumping”. 1 National attention has been drawn to the problem of the „dumping” of uninsured patients in public hospitals. Federal law only deals with the transfer of patients to the emergency room, regardless of possible financial motivation. All transfers, including those requested by patients, must meet the criteria of relevance. A significant portion of the confirmed violations was that the patient had not been adequately screened for emergency conditions. The hospital and physician responsible for the care of a patient transferred in violation of the law may be subject to Medicare sanctions, including termination or suspension of participation and fines of up to $50,000 for each event.
The proposed rules confirm that GPs who provide unpaid emergency rooms under a verbal agreement can be subject to sanctions for breaches. Ultimately, it will become clear that older adults will only be protected from the humiliation of patient dumping if society and the health care industry recognize their inherent value as an important segment of contemporary American life. Congress recognized the need for the public to reduce the incidence of patient dumping when it enacted the anti-dumping provisions COBRA and EMTALA.11 Section 1395 of EMTALA provides in the relevant part: „When a patient in a hospital has a medical emergency that has not been stabilized. The hospital should not transfer the patient unless the transfer to that facility is appropriate. (42 U.S.C. §1395(C)(1)(B) (1994)). EMTALA applies to hospitals that receive federal funding from the Medicare and Medicaid programs and provides for civil fines against participating hospitals and physicians who violate them.12 Also known as „demarketing services” or „patient combination management”2, patient dumping refers to the hospital practice of transferring or refusing to transfer poor people. uninsured or otherwise undesirable.3 Patient dumping originates from the common law rule of tariff prohibition.4 This rule states that hospitals are not required to admit and treat all patients who seek care and, in some cases, are not even required to provide reasons for patient rejection.5 Hospitals often „discharge” patients who do not have health insurance or who only have Medicaid insurance. Hospital services are coming – a program that doctors know offers low reimbursements. Economic pressure on hospitals over the past decade has increased the impact of patient dumping in cases covered by the Tariff Prohibition Rule.6 This rule, along with the ability of hospitals to refuse medical treatment, was superseded by the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA) of 1986, 42 U.S.C. §1395dd (1994) and the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Work Act (EMTALA).
42 U.S.C. §1395dd (1994) – an amendment to COBRA. Delgadillo responds to patient spillage [Press release]. Los Angeles, California: Los Angeles City Attorney Rocky Delgadillo gets a settlement with the hospital on patient dumping. 26 June 2008. www.lacity.org/atty/attypress/attyattypress6954091_06262008.pdf. Retrieved 15 November 2008. The dumping of patients is contrary to the Federal Act on Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Work (EMTALA). EMTALA was adopted in 1986 and aims to prevent any refusal to care for insolvent patients [2].
It imposes three requirements on each hospital participating in Medicare and imposes monetary penalties on physicians or hospitals that do not comply [3]. Participating hospitals must: (1) conduct health screening tests, (2) provide the necessary stabilizing treatment to any patient seeking emergency medical care in an emergency department, and (3) hospitals that are unable to do so (1) and (2) transfer the patient to a facility that can provide these services in accordance with EMTALA guidelines [4]. Recent cases in Los Angeles show that the threat of hefty fines could deter the practice of dumping patients under state law. The Los Angeles city attorney obtained a settlement with the Methodist hospital amid allegations of patient dumping that required the hospital to implement detailed protocols for the discharge of homeless patients. The hospital will also contribute $215,000 to fund recreational beds for the homeless at The Salvation Army`s Bell Shelter and pay $5,000 in civil fines and $20,000 in investigative costs [19]. Kaiser Hospital entered into a similar agreement in May 2007, which resulted in court-ordered protocols for the appropriate discharge of homeless patients, as well as $500,000 in donations to a charitable foundation providing services to the homeless and $5,000 in civil penalties [19]. The underfunded health care system in the United States is causing dumping and denial of care for patients. Caring for patients who don`t have insurance is expensive, and much of the treatment is often without reimbursement. From 1994 to 2005, the number of emergency room visits increased by 18%, from 93.4 million to 110.2 million per year, a rate that coincided with rising care costs and declining reimbursements from managed care organizations and other payers, including Medicare and Medicaid [21]. This trend disproportionately affects low-income patients, who typically do not have access to medical care and often seek it in emergency rooms. In response to rising medical care costs, states have taken a number of cost-cutting measures, including reducing Medicaid eligibility, benefits, and provider payments [22]. As Clay Mickel, spokesman for the American Hospital Association, explained, „The real problem is that the government has not recognized that caring for those in need is its responsibility” [23].
The solution to patient dumping may lie in addressing its root causes, rather than strengthening EMTALA enforcement mechanisms and similar state laws. It has been suggested that EMTALA is ineffective because it has definitional errors and a lack of application.20 In particular, because the key words of the law are vague or not defined at all, courts juggle the statements of medical experts and extract their own definitions.21 EMTALA`s legislative history has often been useful for judicial decision-making – but it also has a basis for broadening the scope of the law. 22 citations for clinical elements of the law, such as failing to perform an adequate medical examination and restricting transfer until a patient is stabilized, increased over the decade studied as a proportion of all citations.