Michigan Court Rules Mcr 2.116

[2] Whether the defendants were actually involved in the introduction of an endotracheal tube and whether they did so in a grossly negligent manner are issues concerning both their immunity from prosecution, MCR 2.116(C)(7), and their possible right to judgment as a point of law, MCR 2.116(C)(10). That`s because, as government employees, they are generally immune from prosecution for acts that are not based on gross negligence. MCL 691.1407(2)(c); MSA 3,996(107)(2)(c). An application under MCR 2.116(C)(10) must be supported by affidavits, statements, admissions, or other written evidence. MCR 2.116(G)(3)(b). The opposing party must not rely on mere allegations or denial of a pleading, but must set out certain facts by affidavits or other appropriate means to demonstrate that there is a real problem with the proceedings. MCR 2.116(G)(4). All these supporting and opposing elements must be considered by the court. MCR 2.116(G)(5).

If an application under Article 2.116(C)(7) of the RCM were considered in the same manner as an application under Article 2.116(C)(8) of the MCR, the respondent`s affidavits and relevant documents of the applicant would not be relevant, since the court would be obliged to simply treat the allegations in the complaint as true. However, MCR 2.116(G)(5) provides that the court must consider affidavits and other evidence submitted by the parties. Neibarger v. Universal Cooperatives, Inc., 439 Mich 512, 532, No. 29; 486 NW2d 612 (1992). Therefore, all these documents have been duly reviewed by the following courts. [6] As noted above, the respondent`s application was made under all three paragraphs. [2] However, the District Court expressly granted a summary injunction on the basis of state immunity. Thus, the summary injunction in this case was issued pursuant to section 2.116(C)(7) of the RCM. However, the practical effect of these maxims is often directly contradictory. If, as in the present case, the defendants make affidavits contradicting the claims of the application, it is not possible *434 to comply fully with both rules, the District Court cannot at the same time consider all the allegations well made to be true and take into account the additional documents submitted in support of the application and the dismissal thereof. [6] A party filing an application under Article 2.116(C)(10) of the MCR must support the application with affidavits or other appropriate documents (MCR 2.116(G)(3)(b), and the opposing party cannot rely on pleadings, MCR 2.116(G)(4).

The difference between an MCR 2.116(C)(7) application and an MCR 2.116(C)(10) application is that an applicant under MCR 2.116(C)(7) is not required to submit supporting documentation and the party rejecting the application is not required to respond in the same manner. In addition, the content of the complaint must be accepted as truthful, unless the applicant`s affidavits or other appropriate documents expressly contradict. The District Court granted the application for summary injunction and declared the defendants immune. The Court of Appeal overturned that decision. 199 Mich App 191; 500 NW2d 761 (1993). [1] The defendants appealed to the Court of Justice. By clarifying the proper manner of considering an application under MCR 2.116(C)(7), we uphold the judgment of the Court of Appeal. RCM 7.302(F)(1).

2, this refusal could be used to support summary injunction under Article 2.116(C)(10) of the RCM (no misconduct at all) or under Article 2.116(C)(7) (no gross negligence, hence state immunity). The Court of Appeal quashed the District Court`s summary order. We reaffirm this result. However, it is necessary to clarify the Court of Appeal`s analysis. An application under section 2.116(C)(8) of the MCR cannot be supported by affidavits, statements, confessions or other written evidence. RCM 2.116(G)(2). In order to examine such an application, the Court of First Instance has to rely only on the procedural documents. MCR 2.116(G)(5).

The requirements for an application for a summary order and the manner in which such an application is considered by the trial court vary depending on the type of application. An application under MCR 2.116(C)(7) may be supported by affidavits, statements, admissions or other written evidence. RCM 2.116(G)(3). When these elements are submitted to the court, they must be taken into account. MCR 2.116(G)(5). In this case, the plaintiff brought an action alleging that her deceased died as a direct result of the defendants` improper and careless insertion of an endotracheal tube. The defendants then filed affidavits essentially saying that the plaintiff sued the fake defendants, that they never inserted such a tube, or that they had anyone else inserted it. [5] The Applicant responded with documents to support her assertion that the respondents were the persons responsible for the death of her deceased. The plaintiff sued two Northville doctors, claiming they were responsible for the incorrect insertion of an endotracheal tube. The defendants responded with an application for a summary injunction. The application was supported by the defendants` affidavits in which they swore that they had not been involved in the insertion of such a tube.

I would allow the appeal so that the profession can educate the members of the Court of Justice on how or why the Michigan rule and its apparent adherence to an inconsistent approach to application practice are superior to the approach under FR Civ P 12(b), 12(c) and 56. In my view, it is unwise to render a decision per curiam on all civil cases in our state, without the participation of the practising Bar Association and an invitation to file amici curiae pleadings of the procedural judiciary. These two principles are accurately attributed to Haywood, and they have also been presented together in other decisions. [3] Similarly, each Haywood step is supported by the published decisions of the Court of Appeal. [4] [3] See, for example, Marrero v. McDonnell Douglas Capital Corp, 200 Mich App 438, 440-441; 505 NW2d 275 (1993); Simmons v. Apex Drug Stores, Inc., 201 Mich App 250, 252; 506 NW2d 562 (1993); Jones v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Ins Co, 202 Mich App 393, 396-397; 509 NW2d 829 (1993); Skotak v. Vic Tanny Int`l, Inc, 203 Mich App 616, 617; 513 NW2d 429 (1994). See also Wade v Dep`t of Corrections, 439 Mich 158, 162-163; 483 NW2d 26 (1992). The applicant`s deceased was a long-time resident *431 of Northville Regional Psychiatric Hospital.

He suffered an epileptic seizure on February 6, 1989 and was taken to St. Mary`s Hospital in Livonia, where he died. The applicant`s reply to the request was supported by two documents. One was a letter from the doctor expressing the opinion that the pipe had been introduced through gross negligence. The second was an emergency room report submitted by the applicant in support of her claim that the tube at issue was inserted at St. Mary`s Hospital prior to the deceased`s arrival. Lakin, Worsham & Victor, P.C. (represented by Larry A. Smith) on behalf of the plaintiff. At one point in its discussion, the Court of Appeal stated: The reasoning of the percuriam opinion seems to be that „what was, is”.

[1] The Court of Appeal subsequently refused to repeat. Unpublished Order dated May 25, 1993 (File No. 134858). [4] Compare Montgomery v Detroit, 181 Mich App 298, 302-303; 448 NW2d 822 (1989), Chivas v. Koehler, 182 Mich App 467, 471; 453 NW2d 264 (1990) and Harrison/Director of Dep`t of Corrections, 194 Mich App 446, 449; 487 NW2d 799 (1992), with Mollett v. City of Taylor, 197 Mich App 328, 332-333; 494 NW2d 832 (1992), Brownell v. Garber, 199 Mich App 519, 529; 503 NW2d 81 (1993) and Diversified Financial Systems, Inc v Schanhals, 203 Mich App 589, 591; 513 NW2d 210 (1994). *435 In the present case, the Court of Appeal duly considered all the evidence adduced in support of and opposition to the applicant`s claim and correctly stated that „it was not appropriate to reject the applicant`s claims at this stage of the proceedings”.

199 Mich App 193.