Before I get back to the legal issues, I need to fill out some of the factual history, both in terms of the planning proposal and the attempts to resolve drainage issues. The planning application for the current development was submitted to the County Council Planning Authority in June 2006. The planning officer`s report referred to the drainage issue and ongoing discussions with DCC. It was noted that if off-site infrastructure improvements were required, they could be supported by a „Grampian” condition or section 106 agreement. The application was submitted to the Planning Committee on December 12, 2006. According to the protocol, the planner stated that the construction work of the houses could only take place after drainage. Article 106(6) allows a dispute on the merits of a refusal to be submitted to the Director of the Water Services Authority („OFWAT”). Although OFWAT was consulted in this case, no formal decision was sought. It is not alleged that this provision in any way limits the power of the judge to decide on questions of law. Barratt is a major home builder. She participates in the development of a site in Llanfoist, Abergavenny.
It has a building permit dated May 14, 2007 for 98 houses and a school. Dwr Cymru Cyfyngedig („DCC”) is the region`s wastewater treatment company. It is the only water and sanitation company in England and Wales that is a not-for-profit organisation. Operation and investment are financed by customer invoices. Stand out from the crowd with the perfect cover letter At the beginning of the process, 38 homes had been built and 31 had been sold. The school opened in September 2008. Interim measures have been taken to store wastewater and collect it in tanker trucks. Current market conditions have delayed further progress in development.
Barratt wanted to connect the development`s drains to the public sewer at Point X, on the street immediately adjacent to the northern boundary of the development site. DCC objected to a connection at this location because of the risk of overflowing the section of the canal immediately downstream. It was ready to allow a connection to a location approximately 3 to 400 meters east at point Y. i) Alternative location If DCC was entitled to require connection to another location because there was a risk of overloading the sewer system The judge answered the first question in favour of Welsh Water. Following Walton J in Beech Properties Ltd v G E Wallis Ltd [1997] EGCD 75, it held that the law allowed an undertaking to require connection at another location in order to avoid interference with the whole network. It considered that the second question, relating to the 21-day time limit, was not appropriate for answering it in the Part 8 procedure, since it raised `somewhat complicated questions of confusion of law and fact` (paragraph 37). He considered that it was not necessary to pronounce on the question of European law. Know your value™. Get a free, personalized salary estimate based on today`s job market. Discussions with Barratt in 2005 and 2006 resulted in a contribution of approximately £13,000 to an evaluation of hydraulic modelling. This assessment highlighted the risk of increased spillage if the compound was manufactured at point X. The existing system is designed to ensure that such an overflow occurs at the „combined sewer overflow” (CSO), which is located in open ground to the east between points X and Y.
It has been calculated that connecting point X could lead to a 29% increase in overflow cases when the development is fully built. It was recommended either to improve the appropriate section of the canal or to connect it to another location downstream. This was followed by discussions between Barratt and CDC on alternatives. Article 106, which is directly at issue, confers the right to be connected to the public sewerage system. The relevant parties are: (a) the owners or occupants of premises located in the area of a funeral home; or (iii) European law, if the response is affected by the EU Urban Waste Water Treatment Directive (91/271/EEC). ii) The 21-day period If DCC has lost the right to object to the connection under point X by serving its response outside the 21-day period provided for by law. In comparison, reference was also made to subsection 8, which grants greater discretion to refuse a connection in Greater London, where a sewer is used for the general intake of wastewater from other public sewers. A private link may be refused on „such grounds as the funeral director deems appropriate” and there is no right to ask OFWAT to contest the refusal. The site has been considered suitable for residential development since at least 1999, when it was allocated in the draft Monmouthshire Unitary Development Plan.
However, it was accepted that improvements to the public sewerage system (estimated at around £200,000 at the time) would be necessary to enable the development and that DCC would reject any proposal to that effect in the meantime. On 29 May 2007, Barratt served a notice pursuant to Article 106 of its proposed connection to Point X. DCC replied on 25 June 2007, purporting to approve the proposal, but stated that the connection should take place at point Y. The letter stated that the connection was to be made either by laying a new sewer or by upgrading the existing sewer and that the seizure procedure under section 98 of the 1991 Act could be used to overcome any problems with the intervening landowners. The DCC then laid concrete around the sewer at point X to prevent a connection to it. Mr. M. Sheridan acted on behalf of the respondent. Section 94 imposes a general obligation on every sewer company to provide and maintain a public sewer system to ensure that its area is „efficiently drained.” Section 98 requires a funeral home to comply with a requirement to provide a public sewer for domestic use, but this requirement is paid by the person who requests it. This is an appeal from a decision of Justice Wyn Williams.
It raises important questions about the nature and scope of the rights conferred by section 106 of the Water Industry Act, 1991 for connection to public sewers. We were also referred to section 112 of the Act, which sets out the means by which the funeral home may require that the proposed drain or sewer be constructed to be part of the general system. Under this procedure, the funeral director may require the person to construct the drain in a manner that meets the funeral director`s requirements, but section 112(6) requires the funeral director to reimburse the person constructing the drain for any additional costs reasonably necessary to meet those requirements. In my view, this section does not clarify the interpretation of section 106. Mr. A. Porten QC and Mr. S. Gasztowicz appeared on behalf of the complainants. I would also like to highlight clause 107, which states that the funeral director may communicate his intention to make the notification himself, rather than leaving it to the promoter; and section 108, which requires the person giving the notice to give reasonable notice to the funeral director of the actual work.