Definition of Legal Advice Privilege

In England and Wales, the rules on solicitor-client privilege are laid down at common law. Rule 31.15 of the 1998 Rules of Civil Procedure („CPR”) establishes a right of access to documents in civil proceedings and provides that a party to whom a document has been disclosed (i.e. who is mentioned or relied upon in a dispute) has the right to consult that document (if such inspection would be proportionate having regard to the nature of the case) – unless: the disclosing party has the right to refuse such an inspection. [3] The prerogative also extends to counsel for foreign lawyers, provided that they act in a professional capacity in the context of legal advice. It is neither necessary nor relevant to consider the training and experience of a foreign lawyer so that solicitor-client privilege can apply in the case of a foreign lawyer – solicitor`s privilege should apply to anyone working as a lawyer in a foreign jurisdiction. Recent guidance from the Law Society suggests that UK lawyers who are not qualified as EEA lawyers will be treated as third-country lawyers after the end of the Brexit transition period, unless there is an agreement to the contrary. Lawyers from third countries working in the EU are not covered by EU professional secrecy. Therefore, only members of the client who are involved in obtaining and receiving advice from outside counsel are entitled to the privilege of legal counsel. Internal communications of other employees who contributed to obtaining this advice are not protected. One of these rights is solicitor-client privilege. It is a privilege that belongs to the client (not the lawyer) in a client-lawyer relationship. It does not extend to consultants who are not legally qualified. [4] It can therefore only be abandoned by the customer.

In the law of England and Wales, solicitor-client privilege is divided into two types: advisory privilege and litigation privilege, the former being absolute and defined more broadly than the latter. Privilege is a fundamental legal right. It allows individuals and businesses to object to the disclosure of confidential and sensitive documents. There are strict rules about when privileges apply under English law: not all communications with lawyers and other advisers are protected. Privileges can be lost by circulating privileged hardware without proper security. It should also be noted that communication within the client team may not be preferred if it is not intended to seek and receive legal advice. For example, communication between the customer team commenting on the merits of a particular issue may not be privileged. Where an investigation is carried out with a view to proceedings which are not yet ongoing, the main subject-matter of the investigation and any documents submitted in the course of the investigation shall always be indicated, provided that they are the execution of that procedure. This can be done by indicating the proposed plaintiffs or defendants for the anticipated litigation and the expected problems in that litigation; This should be done in terms that you would be willing to use to support a claim of privileges.

The most important decision on the scope of legal advice is now that of the House of Lords in Three Rivers (No. 6).2 In this case, it was asked whether the communication between the Bank of England, its lawyers and its lawyers regarding the content and preparation of the „general statement” submitted on behalf of the Bank in the context of the Bingham inquiry is eligible for legal advisory privilege. With regard also to the type of communication, can legal privilege be claimed? The House of Lords (now the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom) has stated that the existence of the privilege of legal advice depends on the „relevant legal context”. The existence of a relevant legal context depends on whether the advice relates to the client`s „private or public law rights, obligations or remedies”. Where this is the case, the communication must also be such that it is objectively expected that the privilege of the legal opinion applies on the basis of public policy. One of these categories of disclosure is the „presentation counsel” at stake in the Three Rivers case, the „relevant legal context” being the Bingham inquiry. Legal advisory privilege is not limited to advice on the law, but also includes „advice on what to do prudently and reasonably in the respective legal context.” This includes presentation, business or strategic advice when it relates to a client`s legal rights, responsibilities, obligations and remedies.