Although all countries with actively functioning patent systems currently have an inventive step requirement, the need for such a doctrine has been questioned. For example, a „substantial novelty” has been proposed as an alternative approach. [14] In addition, in addition to patents, many countries also have utility models that, in exchange for a shorter monopoly term, have a lower (or no) non-obviousness requirement. The availability of utility model protection minimizes the risk to inventors, developers and manufacturers associated with the uncertainty of the outcome of the non-obviousness analysis (legal dispute) (see below). The non-obviousness requirement sets a higher standard than the parallel requirements for copyright and trademarks. Copyright protection can apply to something that has a modicum of creativity, even if it`s not unique or complicated. Trademark protection may apply to a business name that is not unprecedented or ingenious. The USPTO only has to conclude that the proposed mark would not confuse consumers or overlap with an existing mark. Understanding these different standards can help an applicant determine the form of intellectual property rights they should seek.
The requirement of inventive step or non-proximity is to avoid the grant of patents for inventions resulting solely from the „normal design and development of the product” in order to achieve an appropriate balance between the incentive offered by the patent system, namely the promotion of innovation, and its social costs, namely the transfer of temporary monopolies. [4] The non-obvious bar is therefore a measure of what society accepts as a valuable discovery. [5] Other reasons for the non-obvious requirement are the creation of incentives for basic research instead of „incremental improvements” and the minimization of the „dissemination of economically insignificant patents whose research and licensing are expensive”. [6] The U.S. Supreme Court considered for the first time the issue of inventiveness, non-obviousness/discovery in Evans v. Eaton (20,356,431) in 1822, when she approved a lower court`s interpretation that a patentable improvement must involve a change in the „principle of the machine” rather than a „simple change in shape or proportions.” Currently, such variations are generally interpreted as a lack of novelty rather than an inventive step. The trend that began to develop around 1950 (and now dominates) was to require disclosure of an element of discovery, while granting a monopoly on patents on one or a few „specific applications of [natural] laws” that the discoverer had developed before the publication of the very first revelation. The duality between the non-obviousness requirement and too wide a range of claims should be developed by the U.S. Supreme Court in due course. Perhaps the most complicated and difficult requirement to obtain a patent is non-obviousness. It is described in 35 U.S.C.
Section 103, and generally the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office must determine whether an invention would be obvious to the typical person in the field. This means someone who has a general understanding of the field, but not necessarily someone who has the same level of expertise as the candidate. However, it takes more than what is not obvious to the ordinary person or a person with an average education. This position has raised questions about the need to set the limit of the patentable field, not only with routine improvements, but also with major advances in science, that is, the creation of too many monopolies that can hinder rather than promote the progress of science. Currently, the latter limit is set by the requirement of patentable subject matter (research instruments, scientific theories and laws are not patentable), while the question of how much inventiveness is required to obtain a patent must be defined by the requirement of non-obviousness. [Citation needed] The presence of several positive considerations reinforces the argument of non-obviousness. [Citation needed] Another important finding of Graham was the decision that the non-obviousness of a patent claim is a question of law rather than a question of fact, that is, it must be decided by a judge and not by a jury.
Nevertheless, the court noted that „the condition of Article 103 (Evidence) `is appropriate for several basic factual investigations`. It was a dramatic reversal of 150 years of previous history that treated patent validity issues as factual issues. Non-Transparent in Patent Law: A Question of Law or Fact?, 18 Wm. & Mary L. Rev. 612 (1977), scholarship.law.wm.edu/wmlr/vol18/iss3/7 Nevertheless, Graham`s wording did not know „whether the court wanted to emphasize that evidence is a factual conclusion drawn from findings of evidence or a legal conclusion based on factual investigations.” Insignificance in Patent Law: A Question of Law or Fact?, 18 Wm. & Mary L. Rev. 612 (1977), scholarship.law.wm.edu/wmlr/vol18/iss3/7 Subsequently, the lower courts clarified this issue: although the conclusions on the scope and content of prior art, the differences between prior art and patented subject matter, and the level of qualification in the respective prior art are factual in nature (and are left to a jury), The final conclusion of the obvious is that of the law (decided by a judge).
A finding of proximity under Article 103 is therefore a conclusion that a group of persons may have made the same improvement in prior art as that made by the patent owner. The non-proximity requirement is codified in section 28.3 of the Patent Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. P-4). [18] Neither the pragmatic approach nor the „unusual or surprising consequence” test was developed at this time, as the 1952 Congress took a different approach to determining non-evidence, arising from a subjective factor similar to the inventor`s state of mind (called PHOSITA, i.e., a person with ordinary art abilities). The Graham and KSR guidelines were not affected by the America Invents Act, despite the amendment to 35 U.S.C. §103 General Rule, which was amended on September 16. March 2013 applicable requirement of defined non-obviousness: Novelty refers to one of the patentability tests. To be patentable, an invention must be substantially new. What they mean is that until the same thing has been done, it is new. The non-obviousness test is difficult to pass. And this test requires the creation of a hypothetical person with ordinary skills in the field, whatever he is, it is assumed that he knows all the patents ever granted in this field and reads popular magazines.